Birthdays Are For Kids

October 22, 2008 / 10:37 pm • By Dr. Melissa Clouthier

You know the only sorts of get-togethers that stink worse than birthday parties for adults are baby showers. Check that. Co-ed baby showers are worse. You know when being a girl stinks? It stinks when you’re socially obligated to go to a party where women sit around cooing over baby clothes. Good grief. What a total waste of time. It might actually be a good thing that you’re procreating. It might actually be fun to buy you and the kid a present. It is pretty much guaranteed that it won’t be interesting to watch you sit there opening presents and pretending to be excited about the ugly little frock your mother-in-law bought you. It just won’t. And usually these little shindigs are during football. So, in addition to enduring pastels and nasty cake frosting, attending a baby shower means missing grown men in tight pants smashing the heck out of each other. Not a good trade.

But I digress. This is about adult birthday parties. The author of “Happy Birthday You Bastard”, John Swansburg, has decided to reject all birthday dinners. He makes a compelling case, but it falls apart at his conclusion:

In a way, though, it is I who owe Simon. The piles of jumbo shrimp floating on seas of melted ice; the untouched beds of creamed spinach; the endless rounds of marked-up Beck’s Dark—they flash before me now whenever a birthday dinner invitation comes my way, and I can’t bring myself to RSVP yes. The excesses of Simon’s dinner were what I needed to find the social gumption to swear off such affairs entirely. Throwing a party for your birthday? I’ll gladly attend the festivities. Point me to the bowling shoes and buy me a few frames. Cook me dinner—I’ll bring the Taboo. Otherwise, see you next year, pal.

No. Just no. If you’ve crested 18 years old and aren’t hitting one of the milestones, birthday parties are STUPID. You’re a grown woman or man. Hopefully, you have kids to lavish parties on and if you don’t, lavish attention on nieces and nephews and if you don’t do that, take up some sort of charity work. (And don’t you dare write me and tell me about celebrating your dog’s birthday, because that will provoke a beatin’.)

America is the land of the perpetual child. Yay! I’m 33. Whoopdefriggindo. So what? Now, if family wants to celebrate, fine. If you want to go out to eat with your significant other, fine. If you want to meet with a couple girlfriends or have a guy’s night out, fine. But please, grow up. A person who has hit his late twenties and is going to the bar to have an excuse to get wasted is LAME. And it just gets worse the older one gets.

And a birthday dinner where the birthday boy, Simon, invites disparate friends and then expects these strangers to foot the bill? Super mega double lame. And no, Simon shouldn’t have a birthday party either. And no, his buddy shouldn’t be bringing Taboo over either. It’s weird. And sorry, John, but you shouldn’t be expecting your birthday friend to make you dinner or pay for your frames of bowling.

In this world where no one has kids until they’re 40, it seems that adults are the children. It’s too bad, really. Because for parents, true joy comes from watching the kids faces light up. Their delight and happiness and excitement makes for more contentment than an adult celebrating a birthday.

No birthday parties unless you’ve hit a big date. No birthday dinners where you’re mooching manipulatively. Silly people, birthdays are for kids.

  • Glynn W.

    Amen. You said what needed to be said. I agree.

  • Viola J.

    You wrote a post once “Birthday Worth Celebrating” and your last paragraph in that post was profoundly true. Quite different from your view now,just three years later. Birthdays, if they be for children, or for an adult, or even for an animal, are opportunities to express and celebrate our deep love for that individual. It would be ashamed to do away with that opportunity. Just thinking.

  • http://www.melissaclouthier.com Melissa

    My point wasn’t that it’s not great to be alive and that every birthday is a gift, because it is, no matter how old you are.

    Self-indulgence and immaturity is lame, though. And so while I say celebrate away–dinner, go out even, it’s not cool to make the day into some form of narcissistic pursuit. A birthday isn’t a license to be a jerk.

    And I do think that adults try to perpetuate childhood forever. And again, to clarify: I’m all for keeping a childlike wonder. I’m not for acting like a big baby.

  • Chalmers

    So Viola, you are celebrating birthdays for animals? I can see it now, some poor beaten down pooch with a party hat on… http://www.tiredhead.com

  • Viola J.

    I see your point, Melissa.

    Chalmers, actually, I don’t celebrate Baloo’s birthday (cat) or Kai-Ying’s birthday (dog) but I have a blogger friend who does celebrate his animals birthday’s and I think that is really sweet. He loves them and he honors them in that way because he is just that kind of a person. Kind and warm.

  • Chalmers

    Viola,

    Wow, just wow. I don’t know where to start. First, are you running a Chinese zoo, because those pet names are caaaraaazy. Second, your warm and kind blogger “friend” honoring his pets?!? How do you even honor an animal? Ted Nugent would say that you honor them by killing and eating them. I will have to go with Ted on this one.

    Who feels like a little bbq yorkie?

  • Trish

    I don’t have quite your antipathy for baby showers, largely because we don’t have a lot of money and I really needed the things I got at mine. I was willing to put up with a hen party for that. Anyway, it was at work, and they had pizza.\

    I’ve had parties for my birthday, but they were parties for people I liked on the occasion of a milestone, not gimme fests. A good thing, too, because I didn’t get presents. My husband and I hosted, and fed everyone. It was completely different from the gift-receiving, game-playing, cake-munching fest I gave my young son.

    What astounds, confounds, and amazes me is when a perfectly sane and supposedly adult human being talks about hanging up a Christmas stocking. If grown-ups still believe in Santa Claus. . .
    Well, draw your own conclusions.

  • Viola Jaynes

    Chalmers,your dry outlook is hilarious. My children named my cat Baloo from the movie Jungle Book. My husband named our dog Kai-Ying because it is a Chinese dog.

    I sure hope you don’t have a cat or a dog, or any other kind of little animal in your home. I would be scared, really scared, to step foot in your house…even as a little bug. :-)