Why Homeschooling Will Continue To Grow

January 12, 2009 / 12:48 pm • By Dr. Melissa Clouthier

U.S. News reports that homeschooling is increasing overall but the percent of evangelicals homeschooling is declining:

Brian Ray, president of the National Home Education Research Institute, says recent studies suggest that evangelicals still account for roughly 70 percent of home-schooling families. But the picture has changed dramatically since the 1980s, when conservative Christians launched the movement, he says. “In the early years, you had to be a pretty big believer in something to home-school because there was a lot of adult peer pressure not to do it,” he says. “There are a lot of people who now consider home-schooling who would have never 10 or 15 years ago.”

The National Home Education Research Institute, which supports home schooling, puts the number of home-schooled students above the Department of Education’s estimates, at just over 2 million. The institute’s research has found that home-schooled students score about 15 to 30 percentile points above their public-school peers on standardized achievement tests.

I homeschooled last year and put my kids back in school this year. Despite my worries, they were two years ahead academically. The biggest problem with public school is curriculum. Far too much time is spent on tangential silliness.

Really, education is simple: Make sure a child can read, write, and do arithmetic. Push them so that it’s challenging. My son and daughter both do well at science. In fact, my son’s teachers felt it was his best subject. Guess what? I didn’t “teach” any science. However, as we went through history, we learned about weather (affects war outcomes), volcanoes and earthquakes (destroys societies), earth (certain foods were new in the New World), etc. They had books to read about all that. Their curiosity sought answers. Geography and history are so intermingled as to be one subject. Sociology and psychology is revealed through good literature. History teaches forms of governance.

Parents who want to give their kids an elite education would be wise to check out home schooling. Even if it’s only for a year or two, homeschooling can accelerate a child’s learning and also give them confidence and autonomy. The last is counter-intuitive. My children were forced to learn and figure stuff out because I refused to save their bacon every time they found a topic challenging. They also couldn’t get the privilege of reading until they finished their work. And there was no pressure. They could take ten minutes or two hours to conquer an idea. They could take the time they needed.

I was going to do a book review on Outliers: The Story of Success “>Malcolm Gladwell’s book and may still do that, but one point he noted is that the rush to do work, the time-pressure–especially in math–often causes kids to give up and conclude, falsely, “I’m not good at math”, when the problem is really just not enough time to understand an idea. His book was an unintentional endorsement of homeschooling in many ways. (He also talks about year-around school–something many homeschoolers do anyway.)

Homeschooling will continue to grow because it is an excellent form of education. Parents can choose curricula. Kids can learn at their own pace. This is something that doesn’t just appeal to evangelicals, but all parents wanting to give their kids every possible advantage.

Cross-posted at RightWingNews.com

  • http://www.thefriendsofamerica.org Dan

    Hi, I’m a…um…long time listener-first time caller…you know what I mean.

    I wanted to share this article in regard to your post on homeschooling – I believe more parents need to know and influence what’s actually happening in our public school systems (but if you think it takes a village to raise your kids, then you don’t need to read any further).

    With the of pushing lifestyle and social agendas, warped/one-sided versions of history and trying to teach “self esteem” there are many reasons for all parents, not just evangelical or conservative, to choose home schooling – I’ve linked an article below, not trying to self-promote, but to show just one example of how the public (and many private) schools are not willing, and in many cases just unable, to teach to any but the mediocre cross-section of American kids.

    Joey’s Bridge: A story of ambition in the new America
    http://blog.thefriendsofamerica.org/?p=47

    The school environment that squashes ambition, encourages students to just “fit in” and apparent lack of concern about it by administrators is reason enough for me to home school my kids.

    Thanks for listening

  • Trish

    Wow.
    Thanks for that link, Dan.
    That’s exactly why I homeschool my kid. Children are not cookies, and cookie-cutter education will not do. One size does not fit all.

  • Glynn W.

    Nice post, Melissa. I really enjoyed Malcom Gladwell’s book – in fact I suggested it for my next book club.

    My question for you is the same that I will ask our group – how has the information he presented changed how you will rear your kids?

  • http://melissaclouthier.com Dr. Melissa Clouthier

    Glynn,

    Well, my biggest concern coming out of the book is my daughter’s age. She is young for her class– a full year younger than her GT reading group, in fact. I worry that her immaturity will put her behind.

    I will continue to work with the kids academically over the summer (especially math–they’re addicted to reading, so that’s not a problem) and continue to give them as many varied experiences as possible until they hit on “the thing”. Also, I have upped the piano practice just so they have that area of mastery for sure.

    Also, if they have a love, I’m going to cultivate it as much as possible. Already, I didn’t care about what college they chose as I think Ivy educations are overrated anyway. The key is love of something and hard work and dedication to that something.

    How about you? What did you come away with from Outliers? I thought it was a very interesting book. Distressing, too. The unused talent he described literally brought me to tears. The over-achievement was heartening.

  • http://www.rightklik.net/ Jason

    I was homeschooled from 2nd through 8th grade. There are big advantages and big disadvantages to this approach. Homeschoolers tend to be more independent and that, of course, is good. But there is a lot to be said for a more systematic approach to education. Homeschooling should be attempted by highly motivated parents only.

  • Glynn W.

    Melissa,

    I think my takeaways from the book are very similar to yours. It has already become “de rigueur” here to delay the start of your child’s kindergarten. We are wondering how to handle this for both of ours.

    Personally, I started school when I was four. I was fine academically, but that gap is HUGE physically for boys when other kids are starting when they are six. I remember being stunned after having just lost a race in high school, and looked over to see the winner was sporting a full beard.

    I didn’t even have peach fuzz.

    Other than that, Gladwell brought home the fact that opportunity is everything. As if parenting weren’t already hard enough!

  • Pingback: The Enlightened Redneck » Words Of Home-Schooling Wisdom