Inglourious Bastards Basterds–UPDATED

August 26, 2009 / 3:23 pm • By Dr. Melissa Clouthier

Inglourious Bastards might be Quentin Tarantino’s best movie so far. As expected, it’s full of gruesome violence, gratuitous splattering blood, and revenge fantasies. For the subject, it’s all to the good: Nazis die.

Tarantino has some messages for everyone though and they aren’t politically correct. First the trailer. Here are some of the lessons from the movie:

1. Enhanced Interrogation works: The reason William Wallace from Braveheart fame was so remarkable was because he didn’t break. Nearly everyone, eventually breaks. When one gets a bad guy to spill the beans, good guys get saved. It ain’t pretty. But sleep deprivation, psychological discomfort, and in Tarantino’s case, a public head bashing are very effective means of extracting information.

2. There are bad guys. Now, in this politically correct world, only the Nazis may be used as bad guys. Don’t mention the barbary of Native Americans or current slave traders, or Hugo Chavez. Hell, don’t mention the barbaric acts of actual barbarians–the Barbary pirates. These days, the only acceptable bad guy is of German extraction. Anyone who is labeled “bad” is labeled Hitlerian. For fun though, when you go see the movie, just put an Islamist in the place of the Nazi. Every time. Just imagine a freedom hating terrorist biting it hard. It’s profoundly satisfying. If Tarantino were really that edgy, he’d have chosen a more relevant bad guy, but in these times, naming evil is passé.

The movie wins points artistically. The dialogue amusing. Among the blood, guts and nonsense, the story pushes forward with anxiety-producing anticipation.

What made me love the movie most, though, didn’t occur on the screen. The packed theater that made my vengeance-loving heart glad.

So, Americans still hate villains. Americans still want evil doers to pay. After years of mushy, morally ambivalent tripe like Crash, a movie comes out that’s pure good and evil. Well, not so pure. Because war isn’t pure. It’s messy, bad things happen, good people die and sometimes the best soldiers are just this side of normal. Righteous vengeance though, is satisfying. People want evil, innocent-killing psychos to pay–preferably with their lives.

Primal? Uncivilized? It’s pretty to think so. More like, normal people recognize that tolerating evil encourages evil. You know, like the Iranians who repeatedly raped a young boy who defied the Iranian leadership during the protests. That evil.

So, while I’m still waiting for Quentin Tarantino to show some real courage and portray the monstrosity that is Islamofascism–the psychotic Muslim element who carry around Mein Kempf for moral encouragement–I’ll take what I can get. And right now, a movie where the bad guys get incinerated is profoundly satisfying.

It’s nice to see the good guys win. It’s nice to see the bad guys suffer and die. I’m hoping that Inglourious Bastards starts a trend. Now, to choose a more timely enemy.

P.S. Brad Pitt is hot. And the way he says “Nazis” makes me smile. I’m saying it that way from now on. Nat-zees.

P.P.S. This is why I feel no shame about vengeance fantasies. There is no death painful enough to balance the inhumanity of what some evil bastards will do in the name of their despicable cause.

The moral equivalence crowd can shove their sanctimony up their collective ass. There are people right now who loved seeing Americans die in the World Trade Center. They relished it and still do. The Lockerbie bomber, Al Qaeda, the Taliban all glory in their death cult. No reasoning, no gentleness will change their black souls. Just as Nazis felt justified in their abject cruelty, so do the Islamofascists who carry out their modern mission of freedom killing violence.

The only solution? Kill the killers.

After reading Rachel’s post, I’m going to screw up my courage and go visit the site of the Twin Towers. Even though just typing this post makes me angry enough to cry at the injustice, I will see it. And when I go to Germany, I’ll do that heinous visit, too.

There is a reason America continues to fight this pesky foe. It’s us or them. Let it be them.

UPDATED AGAIN:

Actual, real live Inglourious Basterds courtesy Winston Churchill. I love him even more:

Some were in the Brigade – a unit set up by Prime Minister Winston Churchill in 1944, made up of more than 6,000 volunteers. He said: “It seems to me indeed appropriate that a special unit of the race which has suffered indescribable treatment from the Nazis should be represented in a distinct formation among the forces gathered for their final overthrow”.

The following year, the Brigade was in the front line for the Allies’ final push against the Nazi menace and worked with the rest of the British Army in the immediate aftermath of the war.

Official orders dictated that any Nazis captured should be interrogated, not executed. But the revenge squads within Brigade ranks had other ideas.

Go read the whole thing to get an idea of how the Nazi hunters exacted justice.

By the way, to the liberals out there: Was World War II a revenge fantasy? Because technically, the European theater wasn’t “our” war. I mean Germans didn’t attack us. And that war cost a lot of money. And hell, we still have troops stationed in Europe. I mean, it’s like totally a waste, ya know?

I do not regret that America took the war to the terrorist murderers. A sense of moral outrage should determine foreign policy. Barack Obama’s bland indifference to the people of Iran is telling. Should we go to war there? That can be disputed. But what cannot be disputed is that Iran is a totalitarian, fascist regime that wants to exterminate a whole race of people. IT IS EVIL. To not be affronted by their disgusting philosophy and actions is to show indifference to innocent, freedom-loving people.

The left resisted efforts to get involved in WWII. They didn’t want to see the atrocities of Japan, Germany and Italy, especially, because it didn’t fit their never ending selfish narrative.

Either freedom or tyranny is on the march. It is never static. And freedom must be bought or lost.

UPDATED:

The U.S. declared war on Japan December 8, 1941 in direct response to being attacked. Revenge? The next day, Germany declared war on the U.S. FDR offered monetary support to the British, stepping away from neutrality before this. However, one could argue that going to Europe was taking the fight to the enemy. Perhaps America should have simply played defense. It was not as though Germans were storming Manhattan en masse.

Also, for the “brown people” straw man argument: By defending the Iranian people against their psycho tyrant, I’m suggesting defending “brown people”. What did the war in Iraq become, if not a defense of brown people against Saddam Hussein and his sons and minions? What was the war against Iraq to begin with but a defense of the brown people in Kuwait?

Good grief. There’s evil people of every color. That racism card, though, that trumps everything.

UPDATED AGAIN:

In praise of the Bear Jew:

An old friend just attended the wedding of Eli Lake’s younger brother. I wrote my friend:

Do me a favor, really. Shake Eli’s hand and say thanks to the “Bear Jew” from another Brooklyn Jew, me. He did it Brooklyn style, the way I grew up. Some may have f**ked with me, but none came away unhurt, and never did again.

My old friend sent me this email:

Bruce,
I read your email to Eli and his parents- they all loved it and
that led to the handshake pictured here.

Also, I wrote a follow-up review of Inglourious Basterds here.

  • DaveR

    Dang it Melissa. I haven’t been to a movie since LotR and the Star Wars ones. I am satisfied to wait to Netflix it.

    Now I’m going to have to go see this. :-)

  • filioscotia

    You probably won’t be surprised to know that Inglorious Basterds is based on the true story of a brigade of Jewish soldiers in the British Army.

    These soldiers made it their mission in life to track high ranking Nazis down and kill them, during and after the war. And they did it very well, which is one of the reasons the former Nazis worked so hard to find places to disappear into over the years.

    It was nothing less and nothing more than revenge, and they often took their revenge in some highly imaginative ways. It’s an amazing story.

    Check it out at http://luishipolito.wordpress.com/2009/08/11/true-story-of-nazi-hunters-behind-new-tarantino-thriller/

  • http://www.hairyfishnuts.com/ salvage

    Wow.

    You think movies are real.

  • Green Eagle

    “The left resisted efforts to get involved in WWII.”

    You should try reading a history book or two. Opposition in America to entering into World War II was almost entirely a product of the right, and the Republican party.

    Or are you already aware of this well known fact, and you are just an unapologetic liar?

  • 11B40

    Greetings:

    Once again, the POW calculus:

    1) You don’t ever want to fight anyone twice;

    2) Some POWs may have useful information;

    3) Capture, relocation and detention of POWs requires the
    use of scarce resources.

    If I catch them, I’ll do the math.

  • Leeds man

    The left resisted efforts to get involved in WWII

    FDR was a conservative?

  • Twisted_Colour

    Hooray for Churchill!!

    He’s the man to call when you have an angry, right-wing thug infestation.

  • Trevor J

    I don’t think we saw the same movie. The one I saw found the Basterds to be fairly incompetent, though brutal. SPOILER: It turned out that a French woman and a double-dealing SS officer were necessary to accomplish what the Basterds failed at. Brad Pitt’s character is meant to be a useful fool, not a hero.

    Did you also notice the Audience cheering the slaughter of The Bad Guys in the movie they were watching? Did your own urge to cheer on-screen violence give you even a moment’s pause? This movie is part of that “moral equivalency crowd.”

    Seriously, go see the movie again. You might learn something this time if you don’t fantasize about slaughtering brown people the whole time.

  • Shon Bury

    You should actually learn history before you try to comment on it. You’re dangerously ignorant.

    By way of example:

    “I mean Germans didn’t attack us.”

    Perhaps you are familiar with the fact that Germany declared war on us on Dec 8th, 1941? And that their subs had been sinking American ships for years, and that they were at war with our allies?

    Others comment on your “Liberals didn’t want to go to war against the axis” crap. Good on them.

    Your knowledge of history is either feeble or you are a liar. I suspect both.

    scb

  • Scott

    you can’t be serious,

    if enhanced enterrogation works because the movie says so, then so do time travel and giant talking robots.

  • MaryRC

    technically, the European theater wasn’t “our” war. I mean Germans didn’t attack us.

    Do you not know that Germany declared war on the United States? When a country formally declares war on you, it becomes your war, don’t you think?

    The left resisted efforts to get involved in WWII.

    You probably think that FDR was a Republican.

    By the way, did you ever happen to hear of a little conflict called the Spanish Civil War? I’m guessing you haven’t, but bear with me here. I’ll try to keep it simple.

    Shortly before WWII, fascists rebelled against and eventually overthrew the government of Spain. The fascists had the support of Hitler and Mussolini. The US and other Western countries stayed out of it but individuals from Western countries fought for the Spanish government against the fascists. These volunteers were called the International Brigade. They were, all of them, leftists.

  • baronelmo

    Some uber-patriot needs to direct one of those high body-count horror films where all the victims are Muslim. One after the other, in a glorious brown-hued bloodletting. The Iranian mechanic on the corner, the Lebanese hair stylist at the strip mall, Abdullah the paper boy… hell, throw in a Sikh or two just for giggles.

    You’d have a theater filled with right-wingers, coats draped casually across their laps, moaning in ecstasy at every exploding cranium and shattered rib cage. I bet Dr. Clouthier would stay for two screenings.

  • http://gollyg.blogspot.com Dr Zen

    “Or are you already aware of this well known fact, and you are just an unapologetic liar?”

    Let’s just say they’ll be building igloos in Hades before Dr Clouthier says sorry for anything she writes here.

  • ice9

    What are you a doctor of? Because it sure ain’t history, or anything touching on reality.

    Oh, and just because a movie is vaguely related to a true story doesn’t make it true.

    Oh, and TARANTINO.

    ice9

  • MattMinus

    @ice9

    She’s a chiropractor, so not really a doctor.

    For the sake of Irish babies, I hope she never reads “A Modest Proposal”.

  • Doc Washboard

    “For the sake of Irish babies, I hope she never reads “A Modest Proposal”.”

    My friend, today you have won the Internets.

  • DKF

    The left resisted efforts to get involved in WWII.

    The LEFT??? American isolationism was a phenomenon of the LEFT??? Do you know anything at all about 20th Century American history?

  • charles pierce

    Are you high?

  • tgb1000

    If you look at the prescription bottle, you’ll see that there are precise directions regarding dosage and timing.

  • Paul_D

    “The left resisted efforts to get involved in WWII.”

    Who knew that William Regnery was a dirty hippie? Thanks Doc!

  • The Third Policeman

    Melissa, you have me all twisted around in what I’m supposed to say to smug liberals in public and to commentators when I appear on TV and the radio.

    During WWII, the Republicans in Congress resisted every effort by FDR to aid in the ETO, including Lend-Lease, and only agrred to join the fight when Hitler declared war on the US on 12/8/41. Yet you say they were “the left” during WWII – so does that mean Right, now, was Left, then? I need to make sure, so I can argue my way out of this trap when some lefty tries to trick me.

    Also, maybe you could help me with something else. The Right has been calling Obama a fascist and a Nazi, which I know is correct because Jonah Goldberg proved that Fascism = Left, but now I see that since it’s bad to call someone a Nazi, only the left is doing it: LaRouche people are doing it and they are Dems so the left is calling the left Nazi. But I see some, like Ace of Spades, who are calling Obama a Nazi. Does that mean Ace is really LaRouce = Dem = Left? Is the Right really crypto-left, i.e. Nazi? It’s really confusing to know who is Right, is it the right?

  • Mortimer Peacock

    In what ways did “the left” resist getting involved in WWII? Was this the same left that included FDR, who agitated for a principled alliance with Britain while Republican isolationists tried everything to keep us out?

    Or are you talking about British politics, where the Tory Winston Churchill (and a group of other, younger rebel Tories) joined with the Labour Party and the Liberals (Lloyd George, etc.) to overthrow the appeasing Conservative government of Neville Chamberlain?

    Or are you talking about Continental stuff, like the left-wing partisans in Italy that fought against Mussolini? Or the lefties, Catholic and secular, that formed the Resistance in France?

    What exactly do you mean?

  • Mr. Wonderful

    “Should we go to war there? That can be disputed. But what cannot be disputed is that Iran is a totalitarian, fascist regime that wants to exterminate a whole race of people. IT IS EVIL.”

    Do you ever read yourself? Do you have an ounce of self-awareness? You contradict yourself within two sentences. “That can be disputed”? STEP UP! Show some of the courage you seem to think is real when they show it in a movie, Doctor. “Disputed” is for weaklings and liberal appeasers, isn’t it?

    Say YES, THEY ARE EVIL AND WE MUST OBLITERATE THEM! That’s what the rest of this post explicitly says, isn’t it? That’s what makes your “vengeance-loving heart” beat faster, isn’t it?

    Either that, or get back on the meds, Doc. People are beginning to talk.

  • Shon Bury

    It appears, Dr. Melissa, that you are an idiot and should cease blogging about subjects you know nothing about. Unless you want your stupidity called out by dozens of people who are not doctors but who are clearly far more intelligent than you.

    scb

  • Dr. Feelgood

    This is the most compelling argument I’ve read to prohibit the use of public funds for chiropractic treatment.

  • markg

    I just came here for a few laughs, not to drown in a sea of stupid.

  • Gus@jamfsoftware.com

    Wow, I love that almost all of these comments are calling you out on your ignorance. Well done, all.

  • Flavor Flavius Julianus

    For your clients sake, I hope you are a much better chiropractor than you are a historian.

  • Greg

    This post is hilarious. I’ve never heard of you, Melissa, but kudos — you’ve out-schlusseled Debbie Schlussel.

  • DLS

    I suppose the Vichy collaborators were leftists, too, and the Resistance all good conservatives.

  • JCK

    I note that in your “Post a Comment” rules you note:

    * Comments that are inappropriate, rude, completely stupid, or obviously meant to bait others into a flame war may be deleted…

    If you were following your own rules, this post wouldn’t exist

  • resolvedwaldron

    Oh my, a totally befuddled, distorted, and mendacious piece of writing. It is heartening to see from all the responses that you are considered, oh what’s the word, wacky. In fact I would say the Queen of Wackiness–you rule the wacky kingdom, trust me, you do!

    I don’t know what elementary, secondary school or college you attended, but it does say soemthing about the United States education system. Or perhaps, a better explanation is that you are educated way beyond your intelligence.

    To be so ignorant of World War II is mind numbing. Please go back and do some studying and research on WW II and let us know if you come to the same wacky conclusions. Start with the “Rise and Fall of the Third Reich” by Wm Shirer–it is the volume most start on as an introduction to WW II.

    By the way, please correct you correction, Hitler wasn’t all that sure on how to approach the Japanese bombing of Pearl Harbor. In fact there were some in the Nazi hierarchy who opposed declaring war on the US. So Hitler didn’t get around to it until December 11, 1941–four days after Pearl Harbor and three days after Roosevelt declared war on Japan.

  • DKF

    Wow, Melissa! I came back to check how the thread was proceeding after my incredulous comment on your historical imbecility, and you don’t have a single defender on this point! How wrong can a blogger be and not humbly retract her erroneous statement? Even Jonah Goldberg has been known to grudgingly and half-assedly admit error. Either you sincerely believe in this profound untruth, or you are a lying, Gingrichian propagandist tossing out rank bullshit to rile up the ignorant against the “libtards.”

    Stick with that lucrative back-cracking gig of yours.

  • http://grandpaboy.blogspot.com/ Decker

    I have a Brad Pitt speech from another movie that I think addresses your post.

    “I’ve been trying to figure something in my head, and maybe you can help me out, yeah? When a person is insane, as you clearly are, do you know that you’re insane? Maybe you’re just sitting around, reading “Guns and Ammo”, masturbating in your own feces, do you just stop and go, “Wow! It is amazing how fucking crazy I really am!”? Yeah. Do you guys do that?”

    There are SO many mistakes I could point out here, and I’m sure they would all be ignored. Let me at least make the point that what happens in FICTION is not the same as what happens in REAL LIFE.

    Otherwise, little boys everywhere would be trying to get bit by radioactive spiders.

  • http://www.branndonu.ca Paul Madryga

    “Enhanced Interrogation works…”

    …In the movies, sure…

    “Nearly everyone, eventually breaks….”

    …including those who don’t have any useful info, but just want the agony to stop, and who will thus tell the torturers (oops, I mean, “enhanced interrogators”…) anything they want to hear, factual or not.

    “The left resisted efforts to get involved in WWII.”

    Tell that to the aforementioned International Brigade from the Spanish Civil War. Tell that to the Right-wingers of the time (like GW’s grandpa Prescott Bush) who were bankrolling the Nazis.

    With all due respect, Doc, history isn’t your strong suit.

  • SFAW

    Youse guys should leave her alone! She based her “resistance to WWII” stuff on information gleaned from Senator John Blutarsky’s scrupulously researched chronicle of the War. His book also provided a lot of the background information for that recent classic, “Liberal Fascism”, by the brilliant Jonah Goldberg.

    So, lighten up, will you?

  • jimmy

    Babe, do yourself a favor and stay away from history. Maybe some posts about cake baking or teabagging or something.

  • http://mryoureonfiremister.wordpress.com/ mryouronfiremister

    Wow. This post exquisitely displays how thoroughly simplistic and historically misguided the foreign policy of the Bush administration was.

    If this were the Onion, I’d say bravo. Since it’s not, I’ll just back away in horror.

  • mike

    I had to read this to believe it. If this isn’t a parody God help us all.

  • dogctor

    Another black and white thinker.
    Us and them.
    Everything nice and neat, easy to peg,
    fits neatly in a box.
    Your knowledge of history of WWII fits on a matchbox. Did you know the Japanese
    Emperor was ready to surrender when the US dropped the bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki exterminating half a million Japanese? This was done to intimidate Russians about nuclear bombs. Us -good guys. Them -bad guys.

    How do simpletons like you make it in life?

  • http://gapersblock.com/mechanics Ramsin

    Some of the (European) Left was guilty of something: SUPPRESSING their desire to fight fascism on the continent (Fascism was a response to “Bolshevism”, Cf., Reichstag fire) when the Nazi-Soviet (or “Molotov-Ribbentrop”) Pact was signed, and the Stalinist line in the Third International changed to a position of non-intervention. A year later and that disappeared, obviously, and (some of) the (European) left changed course again and supported the war they had initially wanted to fight.

    I refer you to an 8th grade history book.

  • T Herling

    It’s too bad my father is no longer with us, or I’d have to tell him that he was not a liberal as he thought he was, but in fact a conservative, based on his having volunteered to join the army and spend several years serving in the Pacific (because he didn’t have “more important things to do” like some Vice Presidents, or have a pimple on his butt like some radio commentators.)