Is Yelling The New Spanking? Yes.

October 22, 2009 / 2:31 pm • By Dr. Melissa Clouthier

Morally superior Gen X moms and dads seem entirely reasonable until they see the limits of “limits” like time-outs, banal blabbing and gentle cajoling. Kids regard their parents with utter contempt. Well, some do. Depends on the kid’s personality. And parents, once exasperated, go there. No, they might not spank their child. They’ll yell. Or arm yank. Or threaten. Or push. Or thump (thwack in the head with fingers). Or pinch. Something, anything, to reorder the disordered relationship–the one where the kid is running the show, and the parent feels drug around by the nose by a two and half foot troll.

The New York Time’s takes on the “overachieving” parents’ angst via Instapundit:

Parental yelling today may be partly a releasing of stress for multitasking, overachieving adults, parenting experts say.

“Yelling is done when parents feel irritable and anxious,” said Harold S. Koplewicz, the founder of the New York University Child Study Center. “It can be as simple as ‘I’m overwhelmed, I’m running late for work, I had a fight with my wife, I have a project due — and my son left his homework upstairs.’ ”

Numerous studies exist on the effect of corporal punishment on children. A new one came out just last month. Led by a researcher at Duke University’s Center for Child and Family Policy, the study concluded that spanking children when they are very young (1-year-old) can slow their intellectual development and lead to aggressive behavior as they grow older. But there is far less data on the more common habit of shouting and screaming in families.

Something jumps out at me: as the child of parents who viewed spanking as their Christian duty (spare the rod and all that), I can assure the researchers it is not like yelling is new. Yelling happened in the bad old days, too.

Re: parenting styles: Kids are resilient. An occasional “losing it” moment isn’t going to scar a child for life.

However, when a parent creates an environment where he or she is consistently out of control, where he chooses to respond to a child in anger, rather than reason, the child realizes the child is in control. Someone owns the buttons. Either, the parent is controlling the nuke button or the kid is. I would suggest that the kid will grow increasingly insecure when he can’t count on mom or dad to be in charge. He doesn’t want to be in charge. He wants to relax into well-known boundaries.

So, parents need to keep an eternal guard on their emotions. Some kids are very smart and manipulative and get a kick out of mom and dad being as easy as a wind-up toy. Teenage boys seem to especially enjoy spinning old mom like a top. The parent teaches disrespect for both himself and the child.

I hate to burst the bubble of New Agey parenting types who scream at their kids for not eating the lentils, you’re no better than the out-of-control spankers of yore. The key is who is in charge? Screaming just declares your impotence just as reckless spanking indicated a desire for immediate control without thought. In both cases, it’s the easy way.

Parenting is brutally difficult. It is a constant personal challenge. The big picture: What is right for the kid? is lost in a personal haze of fatigue, hormones, blood sugar, emotional misery or whatever. Every parent realizes his personal limitations almost immediately–a crying, inconsolable infant is often the first test of many.

So yellers need to knock it off and grow up. Someone has to be the parent. It should be the parent.

  • Yelling is simply lazy parenting or exhausted parenting. Parents are wiped out after working all day and children are starved for parental attention of any kind.

    Early discipline and spanking as necessary facilitates a peaceful, secure home.

  • I completely agree with Indy Jane. Spanking is still necessary to discipline them, and then try to talk to them out of love and explain the reason for spanking. Yelling is another word for impatience.

  • Yelling also becomes common when you are frustrated at not being allowed to spank, and you are not able to gain control any other way.

  • Pingback: Caffeinated Thoughts()

  • O Bloody Hell

    > Teenage boys seem to especially enjoy spinning old mom like a top. The parent teaches disrespect for both himself and the child.

    And it’s not like society discourages it any more — I recall a Taco Bell commercial some years ago which had me avoiding Taco Bell for about 5 years (and I still don’t go there very often, usually when others want to get something there):

    Some obviously uncool, dweebish parents are in a car with their kids. The kids are clearly well fed, cared for to the point of boredom, and anything and everything their parents say to them is met by a sneering “whatever” type of attitude.

    The parents suggest Taco Bell for dinner, and suddenly the parents aren’t quite so uncool.

    — Now, I ask you — what social result would you expect from a commercial that tells kids that they should go ahead and sneer at their parents for being “uncool”?

    I got news for you, kids: The reason parents are “uncool” is because of all the time they might spend “staying cool” is instead spent caring for you and making sure that your needs are fulfilled.

    This sort of thing is a social rot — we allow/encourage the denigration of every positive social value there is, while hyping irresposibility and other negative social values.

    When it all collapses, that will be the underlying cause.

  • Hhe article's content rich variety which make us move for our mood after reading this article. surprise, here you will find what you want! Recently, I found some wedsites which commodity is colorful of fashion. Such as xxxxxxxx that worth you to see. Believe me these websites won’t let you down.

  • jack john

    Best essays, thesis, dissertations, term papers writing and editing services at affordable prices by UK writing professionals.